Mather and Pitts Insurance, Inc.
Call Us: (800) 232-0674

Church and Synagogue Insurance

Depend on us


We've been providing insurance protection to churches and non-profit organizations for generations. Pastors, lay leaders and volunteers have come to depend on us because of our prompt and courteous service, innovative insurance products that meet their needs and budgets, toll-free calling, and our convenient hours.

It's A Matter of Good Stewardship

We know the importance of being good stewards of what God has placed in our care and we extend that stewardship to your purchase of insurance products. Ministries need to insure their property and their liability, but we understand your need to be mindful of insurance costs. So, as independent agents, we work with many companies to design coverages that are comprehensive yet cost-effective.

You can rest assured that you'll get caring, attentive service from people who know your special requirements.

Meeting Your Needs

Package Policies

Our years of experience allow us to create policy packages that provide coverage for your building, your personal property and your liability. We also provide Pastor's Professional Liability and Personal Injury coverage, and in most states, Workers' Compensation coverage as well.

Directors' and Officers' Coverage

Protecting the personal liability of your organization's directors and officers for the decisions they make and the actions they take while in office should be a key component of your coverage package and we can provide bonding for key members of your group, as well as crime coverage and special events policies.

Additional Coverages

Health Insurance

We offer some of the most competitive rates you'll find on traditional indemnity (fee for service) plans as well as preferred provider plans (PPOs) and health-maintenance organizations (HMOs) for both group and individual policies.

Regardless of your needs and budget, we're here to help. To learn more about our innovative products for churches and synagogues, send us an email or call 860.581.4884.