Mather and Pitts Insurance, Inc.
Toll Free (800) 232-0674

Claim Contacts

To report your claim, please contact us directly at:

  • Deep River Office: 860-526-4943
  • East Hampton Office: 860-267-7889
  • Toll Free at: 800-232-0674

However, if our office is closed, you may report emergency claims directly to your insurance company listed below.

  • Andover Insurance: 800-225-0770
  • Brotherhood Mutual: 800-333-3735
  • Bunker Hill: 866-322-2442
  • Foremost/Farmers: 800-435-7764
  • GuideOne Mutual: 877-448-4331
  • MiddleOak: 800-225-2533
  • NLC Companies: 800-962-0800
  • Peerless Insurance: 800-522-7152
  • Plymouth Rock: 866-591-5545
  • Progressive Insurance: 800-274-4499
  • Safeco: 800-332-3226
  • The Hartford: 800-423-0033
  • Travelers: Boat Claims 800-772-4482
  • Travelers: Commercial Claims 800-238-6225
  • Travelers: Glass 866-878-4527
  • Travelers: Personal Lines Claims 800-252-4633